Etsy's New Policy Means Some Items Are 'Handmade In Spirit'

By Ashley Milne-Tyte

Under online marketplace Etsy's new policies, vendors can now use an outside manufacturer to help make their goods.

That is not going down well with some longtime sellers, who are calling the new policies a turnaround from the site's original mission.

"Their moniker is, you know, a place to buy handmade. It doesn't say a place to buy factory-made," says Rae Padulo, a potter who began selling dishes and ornaments on Etsy in 2009.

"There's nothing wrong with factory-made; it's just, that's not what Etsy started out to be," she says. "It started out to be a place where you could get something special, something one-of-a-kind, something made by a human being."

Padulo says Etsy is abandoning makers of handcrafted goods, who, like her, have only one pair of hands.

Etsy CEO Chad Dickerson says the company is still behind lone artisans — they make up most of its 1 million sellers. Still, it wants to support those whose businesses are growing, and under the old rules, that was difficult. Successful vendors were frustrated that they couldn't get enough help with their work.

"We heard from a wedding seller, for example, who said that when wedding season came around she was in a state of mild panic attack because she just reached her limit and was working, you know, 18 hours a day," Dickerson says.

Under the new policy, anyone who wants to work with an outside manufacturer has to apply and be vetted by Etsy, which makes sure the arrangement meets its ethical guidelines.

Continue reading this article and listen to the radio segment on NP...

Thank you: Originally Posted on the Critical Craft Forum !

Views: 105

Tags: Etsy's, Handmade, Items, New, Policy, Spirit, art, artisan, ceramic, craft, More…crafthaus, fiber, hobby, jewelry, produce, product

Comment

You need to be a member of crafthaus to add comments!

Join crafthaus

Comment by Jessica Todd on November 5, 2013 at 5:00pm

I think it's fantastic that those sellers have had so much success on Etsy that they're able to hire employees and grow their businesses - for many (or some) that is the ultimate goal. But maybe that means they've outgrown Etsy. By that point it seems you would have enough name recognition and income to market on your own and sell via your own website or retail stores. Perhaps Etsy is best reserved for those still working toward those goals or those who don't have such high aspirations.

Latest Activity

Carolina Cole joined Parker Brown's group
Thumbnail

Crescent Moon Armoury

Begun in 2005 by metalsmith, Parker Brown, Crescent Moon Armoury is a small business dedicated to the continuing craft of historical armour smithing.  The majority of its work focuses on historical armour for the modern collectors and martial artists.  Each piece is made according to the specific measurements and needs of the individual client.  In a modern world that has forgotten the true meaning of "custom made", Crescent Moon Armoury strives to retain, preserve and advance the true craft…See More
5 hours ago
Fluxplay Jewellery posted photos
9 hours ago
Linda Threadgill posted photos
9 hours ago
Susan Lee Stephen liked Brigitte Martin's blog post Zoe Arnold - The Poetic and the Macabre
14 hours ago
Susan Lee Stephen liked Brigitte Martin's blog post Cindy Steiler - Not Forgotten
14 hours ago
Glen Guarino left a comment for Sean Macmillan
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream.  http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream Feel free to share with other artists & your college…"
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Grace Sheese
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream. http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream"
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Kathy Maves
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream. http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream"
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Kalika Bowlby
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream. http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream  "
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Amber O'Harrow
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream. http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream "
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Ana M. Lopez
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream.  http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream Feel free to share the call with other artists. Regards, Glen…"
yesterday
Glen Guarino left a comment for Gary McNabb
"Please look at our call for our next online Crafthaus show, A Midsummer Day's Dream. We hope you will consider emailing a submission http://crafthaus.ning.com/group/crafthausexhibition/forum/topics/a-midsummer-day-s-dream Feel free to share…"
yesterday
Sarah Holden added 2 discussions to the group SNAG
yesterday
Linda Threadgill is now a member of crafthaus
Sunday
Jina Seo joined Parker Brown's group
Thumbnail

Crescent Moon Armoury

Begun in 2005 by metalsmith, Parker Brown, Crescent Moon Armoury is a small business dedicated to the continuing craft of historical armour smithing.  The majority of its work focuses on historical armour for the modern collectors and martial artists.  Each piece is made according to the specific measurements and needs of the individual client.  In a modern world that has forgotten the true meaning of "custom made", Crescent Moon Armoury strives to retain, preserve and advance the true craft…See More
Sunday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
Sunday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
Sunday
Emilie Pritchard posted photos
Sunday
Crystal Hartman posted photos
Sunday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"Design and Craft Fair, 20 - 22 JuneEarly bird tickets on sale now!Browse products from over 85 innovative designers and makers in this celebration of creativity, featuring the team behind MADE Brighton and London.Be inspired by…"
Sunday

© 2014   Created by Brigitte Martin.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service