Etsy's New Policy Means Some Items Are 'Handmade In Spirit'

By Ashley Milne-Tyte

Under online marketplace Etsy's new policies, vendors can now use an outside manufacturer to help make their goods.

That is not going down well with some longtime sellers, who are calling the new policies a turnaround from the site's original mission.

"Their moniker is, you know, a place to buy handmade. It doesn't say a place to buy factory-made," says Rae Padulo, a potter who began selling dishes and ornaments on Etsy in 2009.

"There's nothing wrong with factory-made; it's just, that's not what Etsy started out to be," she says. "It started out to be a place where you could get something special, something one-of-a-kind, something made by a human being."

Padulo says Etsy is abandoning makers of handcrafted goods, who, like her, have only one pair of hands.

Etsy CEO Chad Dickerson says the company is still behind lone artisans — they make up most of its 1 million sellers. Still, it wants to support those whose businesses are growing, and under the old rules, that was difficult. Successful vendors were frustrated that they couldn't get enough help with their work.

"We heard from a wedding seller, for example, who said that when wedding season came around she was in a state of mild panic attack because she just reached her limit and was working, you know, 18 hours a day," Dickerson says.

Under the new policy, anyone who wants to work with an outside manufacturer has to apply and be vetted by Etsy, which makes sure the arrangement meets its ethical guidelines.

Continue reading this article and listen to the radio segment on NP...

Thank you: Originally Posted on the Critical Craft Forum !

Views: 105

Tags: Etsy's, Handmade, Items, New, Policy, Spirit, art, artisan, ceramic, craft, More…crafthaus, fiber, hobby, jewelry, produce, product

Comment

You need to be a member of crafthaus to add comments!

Join crafthaus

Comment by Jessica Todd on November 5, 2013 at 5:00pm

I think it's fantastic that those sellers have had so much success on Etsy that they're able to hire employees and grow their businesses - for many (or some) that is the ultimate goal. But maybe that means they've outgrown Etsy. By that point it seems you would have enough name recognition and income to market on your own and sell via your own website or retail stores. Perhaps Etsy is best reserved for those still working toward those goals or those who don't have such high aspirations.

Latest Activity

Joy Ude posted photos
20 hours ago
Regina Rose Malone is now friends with Glen Guarino and Leo Genkin
21 hours ago
Brigitte Martin liked Erika Uzmann's photo
yesterday
Chanda Glendinning is now a member of crafthaus
yesterday
Marsea Banister posted photos
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"Job advert, Theo Fennel: Theo Fennell is hiring! We are looking for a Wholesale Coordinator with two or more years experience to support our busy Head of Wholesale. The role is primarily administrative but will involve the successful candidate in…"
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"Our brand new FREE student event 'Make your Mark' is only one month away! If you're a tutor conducting a jewellery or silverware class, or a student studying one of these courses, this event is for you! The aim for the day is to…"
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"Junior Jewellery Mounter Apprentice Join a young & dynamic luxury diamond jewellery company with a London West-end based workshop 6,000 Application deadline: April 22nd 2014 Wonderful opportunity to join a young and dynamic luxury diamond…"
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"The Jewellers and Silversmiths Network (JSN) Message - Beyond Adornment 26 April to 7 June Private view: Fri 25 April, 6-8pm Members of the Jewellers and Silversmiths Network (JSN) have looked at the concept of ‘Message - Beyond…"
yesterday
Niki Grandics liked Bruna Hauert's event RULE THE WORLD, FoC-jewellery and fellowship award 2014
yesterday
John Lunn added a discussion to the group Tapestry of Talents: Bringing Your Whole Voice to Your Craft
Thumbnail

In a state of jazz

Time to shift gears away from science and into music. I play jazz flute and piano and when I read this interview with Branford Marsalis  (sax player who led the Tonight Show band for Jay Leno), it connected with some thoughts I’ve been mulling over about the metal art world. I’ll start with the excerpt and comment at the bottom:“You put on old records and they always sound…See More
yesterday
Sarah Holden added a discussion to the group SNAG
Thumbnail

NEW Perks for Giving Program

SNAG has launched New Perks for Donating!$125 LevelIf you donate at the $125 level you will receive a hand written thank you along with a set of our newest SNAG stickers (or $10.45/mth for 12 months).$250 LevelIf you donate at the $250 level, you will receive a hand written thank you, a set of stickers, and a limited edition hand…See More
yesterday
Anita Mills posted a status
Thursday
Anita Mills posted a status
"New work posted on my Blog! http://anitamills.com/new-from-my-workbench/"
Thursday
Brigitte Martin posted a blog post
Thursday
Brigitte Martin liked Leo Genkin's photo
Thursday
Susan Madacsi liked Brigitte Martin's blog post Scott Hove - Cakeland. Birthdays just got a whole lot better.
Thursday
Brigitte Martin liked Niki Grandics's photo
Thursday
Erika Uzmann posted photos
Thursday
Niki Grandics liked Vincent Pontillo's photo
Thursday

© 2014   Created by Brigitte Martin.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service