Pinterest Concerns or A red letter P will be pinned to their chest.

There is a ton of discussion going on about Pinterest.The opinions are mixed. While Pinterest is a delightfully engaging web site I am very upset by a number of issues surrounding Pinterest. Including but not limited to:

My practical advice is at the top of this post highlighted in beige. IF you want more background surrounding Pinterest keep reading. I hope Pinterest takes actions or they are doomed for a red letter P across their chest for irresponsible behavior.

I think that everyone should discontinue posting on Pinterest for now, but do not delete your account.
Advice from Tom McCarthy on Crafthaus  is well reasoned. He says: "I made a mistake when I deleted my Pinterest account.  I will be rejoining.  Not to re-establish my boards, I still don't want to pin.  But having an account will allow me to correct any misinformation on pins of my work to a limited extent.  Without an account I can view the activity but not comment on it.  I'm not advocating hiding from the issue in my studio.  I just don't want to invest my time in their game.  Member complaints will probably also mean more to Pinterest than "outside agitators.""

Lots of information is surfacing about the issues surrounding Pinterest. The issues are explosive.
At first thought Pinterest was fun, interesting and entertaining. Now I am not so sure. I have stopped pinning.


Read the most recent post on ASK Harriete titled:
An Opinion about Pinterest - "What’s Yours Is Mine"
for a summary on the issues. Below is a running thread from the previous week about Pinterest.

In summary, my recommendation to all artists and makers is to stop pinning until you know all the ramifications of your actions.
ASK Harriete has four  posts about Pinterest.

Pinterest Hot Topics & Copyright Infringement

IP/Internet Lawyer Opinion About Pinterest Terms of Use Policy

Pinterest Search Results Do Reveal Problems AND Revelations

Pinterest The Huge Concern

Pinterest - Quick Tips to Become a "Pinner"

The issues presented here are serious and not just limited to Pinterest, but extend to other photo sharing sites. The most serious issue on Pinterest is that people pin images they don't own.

Here is another post from the Business Insider titled: A Lawyer Who Is Also A Photographer Just Deleted All Her Pinterest ....Read it and think about the images you are posting. Actually, I took a number of my Pinterest images OFF my boards because I realized that I didn't own the images AND didn't have permission of a living artist.



The HUGE ISSUE WITH PINTEREST
is that people  are pinning and repinning images that they don't own, haven't asked permission, and they are not including proper and complete attribution in the description. That is just the tip of the iceberg.

MOST IMPORTANT:  We can't blame other people when we don't take responsibility ourselves.

Make sure the images you pin have a source or resource back to the artist's or makers web site if possible. Include the title of the work, description, and even photo credit if appropriate. This includes posting your own photos. Once they leave your pinboard because someone repinned the image, the connection to the artist may be lost.

Don't pick images off of Google Image Search for Pinterest. Try to go back to the artist's web site or blog. Then at least a future viewer can find out more information about the artist or maker.


Another issue is the "fine print" on Pinterest.

 Here is an [edited] portion of a comment from a reader on ASK Harriete:
 QUOTE begins...

"...But what I do have a HUGE concern about are their terms of use.

Do you know that in their terms of use they explicitly say that:
1. by pinning your own work to their site you are signing over your rights of ownership to your work;
2. that they can then sell that work (I don't think they chose to use that word by mistake);
3. that if you pin other people's work, by doing so you're saying that either own that work or have obtained rights to do the things in number 1 and 2; and 4. that if you don't have rights and they are sued because they sold or did something with an image you pinned; you are a co-Defendant responsible for not only your own defense, but theirs?

Please have a look at these articles which explain this much better than I.
http://artists-bill-of-rights.org/news/campaign-news/pinterest-%11...


http://ddkportraits.com/2012/02/why-i-tearfully-deleted-my-pinteres...

My concern is not whether we play nice with one another; but whether Pinterest will play nice with us!"

END QUOTE

Here is another link brought to my attention on Facebook by Tom McCarthy

Is Pinterest a Haven for Copyright Violations?

Harriete continues:
I don't approve of the Pinterest policy and will look into this further. Stay tuned for more introspection on Pinterest.

More later.

Harriete

Views: 621

Tags: 2.0, art, ask, berman, craft, estel, harriete, pinterest

Comment

You need to be a member of crafthaus to add comments!

Join crafthaus

Comment by Brigitte Martin on March 1, 2012 at 11:40am

The 2Roses just posted an interesting comment regarding the PINTEREST topic:

Standing at the crossroads of what's yours is mine.

Comment by Harriete Estel Berman on February 28, 2012 at 3:11pm

Super thanks for your comment. One person at a time, your complete description could set a new standard, that people will find even more interesting and informative.

Harriete

Latest Activity

The Justified Sinner commented on The Justified Sinner's blog post Long Winter Nights
"Thank you, Brigitte!"
7 hours ago
Brigitte Martin commented on The Justified Sinner's blog post Long Winter Nights
"Happy - belated - birthday!"
13 hours ago
Philip W Ambrose liked Marissa Saneholtz's photo
15 hours ago
Sarah EK Muse posted a photo

Take Home a Piece of Virginia

This Holiday SeasonTake Home a Piece of VirginiaAn ExperienceA MemoryA SkillArtisansCenterofVirginia.org
20 hours ago
Vincent Pontillo is now friends with Frederique Coomans and Marissa Guthrie
21 hours ago
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"ResonanceFM BroadcastsMaking Conversations is a series that originally aired on Resonance104.4fm.Episode 1: Professor Andrew Prescott, AHRC Digital Transformations Research Fellow, talks to Jon Rogers and Justin Marshall about how using digital…"
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
yesterday
Gigi Li is now a member of crafthaus
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"At the Bench http://www.atthebench.com/subscribe/ Andrew is off filming for a few days this week. He is filming one of UK's best loved precious metal recycling companies. Still a bit hush hush at the moment but an interested collection of films…"
yesterday
Rebecca Skeels commented on Rebecca Skeels's group The Association for Contemporary Jewellery
"Head of School - Conservation West Dean College Location: Chichester Salary: Circa £47,000 Hours: Full Time Contract Type: Permanent Placed on: 19th November 2014 Closes: 12th December 2014 Part of The Edward James Foundation Ltd, a registered…"
yesterday
The Justified Sinner posted a blog post

Long Winter Nights

An eventful week which included my 50th birthday! I've been in Edinburgh again for a couple of events, taking in the current show of work by the Northern Irish family of Silversmiths "The McCrory Family" as well as Tania Clarke Hall's incredible jewellery made from leather. My main reason for visiting was to pick up my brooch by Dorothy Hogg from The…See More
yesterday
Alena Stukavcova Dolezalova liked Stefano Pedonesi's photo
yesterday

© 2014   Created by Brigitte Martin.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service